Why Employee Engagement Is Not Enough: Moving from Engagement to Experience

For more than a decade, organisations across Africa have invested heavily in employee engagement. Survey cycles, pulse checks and engagement scores became proxies for organisational health. Yet, despite this focus, many leaders still describe the same unresolved challenges: inconsistent performance, high turnover in priority talent segments, and difficulty in building a compelling employer brand that cuts through in competitive markets.

The truth is increasingly clear: employee engagement, alone, is not delivering the strategic advantage it once promised. The world of work has moved on — and Africa’s most forward-thinking employers are moving with it.

To stay competitive, leaders are shifting from measuring how people feel to designing how people experience work. This move from engagement to employee experience (EX) is proving to be one of the most important evolutions in modern people strategy.

---

Engagement Was a Start - Not the Destination

Engagement tools gave leaders a view of sentiment. But sentiment does not transform performance. Experience does.

A powerful insight emerges from Talent Matters research: even high engagement can coexist with poor performance if the day-to-day experience is fragmented, inconsistent, or fails to support people at key moments that matter in their working lives.

Engagement scores capture how people feel today. Employee experience captures how people work, grow and succeed every day.

This distinction matters because:

• People leave experiences, not surveys.

• People advocate for brands that deliver, not brands that promise.

• People thrive in systems, not slogans.

What EX Does That Engagement Never Could

The leaders featured across GCC’s Talent Matters platform consistently reinforce the same message: the organisations outperforming their markets are those designing deliberate, end-to-end people experiences.

Why? Because EX influences the elements engagement could never reach:

1. EX shapes performance

Organisations with superior employee experiences outperform peers on revenue growth, margin and return on assets. This is not correlation; EX is a strategic input to performance.

2. EX shapes capability

African markets are entering a period defined by skills scarcity, mobility, and shifting workforce expectations. High-performing organisations are now re-architecting jobs, development and mobility pathways around EX — not just policy — ensuring people can learn, stretch, rotate and grow.

3. EX shapes the employer brand

Careers in Africa Employer of Choice data reveals that candidates choose employers primarily for:

• meaningful work,

• skill development,

• innovation,

• and the ability to make an impact ().

These top drivers are all delivered through the experience, not the employment contract.

Why Engagement Alone Fails in African Contexts

Many organisations in Africa face structural talent challenges — mobility constraints, leadership gaps, scarce technical skills, and rapidly evolving digital demands. Engagement scores do not solve these problems.

Experience does.

• Engagement cannot fix broken onboarding — but EX designs onboarding as a competitive differentiator.

• Engagement cannot create leaders — but EX redefines leadership expectations around trust, communication and empowerment, which African professionals consistently cite as critical.

• Engagement cannot unlock diaspora talent — but EX builds the value proposition needed to attract high-potential returnees.

• Engagement cannot retain emerging leaders — but EX builds mobility pathways, capability ladders and meaningful hybrid working models tailored to Africa’s realities.

In short, engagement is a mirror. Experience is an engine.

What This Means for HR Leaders in Africa

The shift from engagement to experience is not cosmetic. It is a strategic reset — and a competitive imperative.

To remain attractive to Africa’s fast-moving talent market, organisations must redesign their people systems around three principles:

1. Think like a customer business

• Talent is no longer a resource. As Talent Matters notes, talent behaves like an investor — choosing where to place its time, capability and advocacy.

2. Architect work for development, mobility and future capability

• If learning, challenge and impact are the top attraction drivers, they must become the spine of your EX.

3. Treat leadership as an experience, not a hierarchy

• Employees judge leaders not by seniority, but by their ability to communicate, connect and create clarity — outcomes repeatedly emphasised in your Talent Matters leadership insights.

---

The Path Forward: From Engagement to Experience

The African talent landscape is entering a new phase. Mobility is rising. Skills demands are shifting. Competition is intensifying. And talent has more choice — and more voice — than ever.

Engagement will still matter. But experience will decide who thrives.

Organisations that invest in EX will build stronger brands, retain key people, develop future leaders, and unlock the productivity required to compete across the continent.

Those who do not will continue to “measure” talent, without ever truly activating it.